Difference Between PLC and SCADA
In this article, you will learn the difference between PLC and SCADA systems. The word PLC means Programmable Logic Controller and the word SCADA means Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition.
Table of Contents
PLCs and SCADA systems are both critical components of industrial automation, they both have different functionalities, and are used in different ways.
PLCs are designed to control and monitor specific equipment or machinery, they have built-in safety and redundancy features and can handle high-speed control loops and precise control.
PLCs operate in real-time and are often used in manufacturing and other industrial facilities.
On the other hand, SCADA systems provide an interface between the operator and the PLCs and other equipment to monitor and control industrial processes.
SCADA doesn’t have any input and output modules for controlling the plant. SCADA gathers data from the PLC and provides historical trending, reporting, and alarming.
SCADA also integrates with other systems such as MES, ERP, and DCS. SCADA provides a higher level of visibility and control over the entire industrial process, allowing operators to make better decisions and improve process efficiency.
Difference Between PLC and SCADA
The below table provides a detailed comparison between PLC and SCADA systems.
|PLC (Programmable Logic Controller)||SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition)|
|PLC Monitors and controls industrial processes||SCADA is a Graphical user interface for operators to access and monitor processes|
|PLC has input and output modules for controlling the plant||SCADA does not have input and output modules|
|PLC Often used in conjunction with SCADA systems||SCADA provides an interface between PLC and the operator|
|PLC more focused on control functionality||SCADA more focused on visualization and operator interface|
|PLC can be used to control and monitor specific equipment or machinery||SCADA can be used to control and monitor entire industrial processes over a wide area|
|PLC operates in real-time, with fast processing speeds and precise control||SCADA can provide a broader view of the overall process and historical data|
|PLC can be programmed with ladder logic or other programming languages||Typically SCADA uses a visual programming interface for creating graphical displays and alarms|
|PLC can be used for simple to complex control logic||SCADA can be used for monitoring the data of the control logic in PLC|
|PLC often used for discrete manufacturing operations||SCADA is often used for any type of process control system for data gathering|
|PLC has built-in safety and redundancy features||SCADA is a simple workstation. We can add some level of redundancy components in the computers.|
|PLC can be configured to interface with other systems using standardized protocols like Modbus, Profibus, etc.||SCADA can be used for tracking the plant data for compliance with industry regulations|
|PLC can handle high-speed control loops and precise control||SCADA provides access to monitor the status of these high-speed control loops.|
|PLC can be integrated with sensors and actuators to control equipment and machinery||SCADA can provide real-time and historical data on the sensors and actuators.|
|PLC has a compact and rugged design, suitable for industrial environments||SCADA is a programming software that can be installed in industrial-grade computers.|
|PLC can be configured to interface with other systems using standardized protocols like Modbus, Profibus, etc.||SCADA software also supports various protocols for interfacing with PLC.|
|PLC can operate independently or as part of a larger automation system||SCADA can provide an overall view of the plant operations and improve decision-making for operators.|
|PLC can be used to control and optimize the production process||SCADA is also used by engineers to know the status of the plant production|
|PLC is a cost-effective solution for small to medium-sized operations||SCADA can be deployed for small to larger operations that require complex and comprehensive monitoring and control|
PLCs are used for control and monitoring purposes, while SCADA systems are used for visualization and operator interface.
PLCs are more specific and localized while SCADA is more general and centralized. Together, PLCs and SCADA systems provide a comprehensive automation solution that can help to improve the efficiency, productivity, and safety of industrial operations.